Center for Coastal Resource Studies

Integrated Rice–Fish Farming Under Climate Variability: Evaluating Water Productivity, Soil Health, and Food Security in Bangladesh

Exploring how integrated rice–fish farming can improve agricultural resource efficiency, diversify food production, and strengthen the climate resilience of smallholder farmers in Bangladesh.

Rice and fish are two essential components of Bangladesh’s food system, contributing significantly to national food security, nutrition, employment, and rural livelihoods. Rice provides the country’s primary staple food, while fish remains an important source of animal protein and essential micronutrients. However, conventional rice monoculture faces increasing challenges from climate variability, including irregular rainfall, seasonal flooding, drought, rising temperatures, and changing water availability.

Integrated rice–fish farming offers an alternative production approach in which fish are cultured within rice fields, allowing farmers to produce two important food commodities from the same agricultural landscape. Instead of using agricultural land exclusively for rice cultivation, this system combines crop production and aquaculture through the coordinated management of water, nutrients, and biological resources.

The system has the potential to improve land-use efficiency, diversify farm production, and generate additional income without necessarily reducing rice productivity. In Bangladesh, where agricultural land and freshwater resources are under increasing pressure, understanding the performance of integrated rice–fish farming under changing climatic conditions is particularly important.

Why is integrated rice–fish farming attracting attention?

Conventional rice farming primarily focuses on grain production, whereas integrated rice–fish farming combines crop cultivation and aquaculture within the same production system.

The relationship between rice and fish can create several ecological and production benefits. Fish can consume insects, larvae, weeds, and other naturally available organisms in rice fields, potentially contributing to biological pest control. Their movement may also influence soil-water interactions and nutrient cycling. Meanwhile, rice plants provide shade and habitat for fish, while the field ecosystem supports natural food organisms such as plankton and benthic invertebrates.

Fish excreta and decomposing organic materials can return nutrients to the production environment. Depending on stocking density, feeding practices, soil conditions, and water management, this nutrient recycling may contribute to improved nutrient availability and potentially reduce the need for certain external inputs.

Another important advantage is production diversification. A conventional rice field generally produces one major crop during a cultivation cycle, whereas an integrated system can generate both rice and fish. This provides farmers with additional opportunities for income generation and household food consumption.

Research by Ahmed and Garnett (2011) highlighted the potential of integrated rice–fish farming in Bangladesh to improve resource utilization, production diversity, and food security compared with rice monoculture.

However, climate variability creates additional challenges. Floods may cause fish escape, drought can reduce water depth and fish survival, and high temperatures may increase oxygen stress. Therefore, evaluating the performance of rice–fish farming under different climatic conditions is necessary to understand where and how this system can be sustainably implemented.

What do previous studies indicate for Bangladesh?

Research conducted in Bangladesh has demonstrated the socioeconomic and production potential of integrated rice–fish farming.

Ahmed, Zander, and Garnett (2011) examined the socioeconomic aspects and production efficiency of rice–fish farming. Their research found that integrated farming can perform competitively with rice monoculture while providing additional benefits through fish production and improved resource utilization. However, limited technical knowledge, production costs, and risks associated with floods and droughts were identified as important barriers to wider adoption.

Similarly, Islam et al. (2015) investigated the adoption and impacts of integrated rice–fish farming in Bangladesh. Their study used household-level survey data from northern and northwestern regions and found positive effects on the welfare of participating indigenous farm households. Access to irrigation, credit, education, and farm resources influenced the adoption of this production system.

More recently, Tabassum et al. (2026) investigated rice–fish farming in Dinajpur, comparing integrated rice–fish plots with rice-only fields managed by the same farming households. Their findings indicated that rice production did not differ significantly between the two systems, while additional fish production contributed to higher farm revenue and profitability. The study reported an average fish production of approximately 2,932 kg per hectare in the integrated system.

These findings suggest that integrated rice–fish farming can contribute to agricultural diversification, household income, and food security. However, its performance under different climate conditions and its long-term effects on soil health and water productivity require further investigation.

How can the performance of integrated rice–fish farming be evaluated?

A comparative research framework can be developed using field experiments, farm surveys, water-quality monitoring, soil analysis, and climate-data assessment.

Two production systems would be evaluated:

  • Integrated rice–fish farming: Rice cultivation combined with fish production in the same field.
  • Conventional rice farming: Rice monoculture without fish integration.

The comparison should consider differences in production, resource consumption, environmental conditions, and economic returns.

1. Comparing rice production and fish yield

Rice yield and fish production should be measured separately in both farming systems.

Important indicators include:

  • Rice production (kg/ha).
  • Fish production (kg/ha).
  • Fish survival rate (%).
  • Average fish growth and harvest size.
  • Fish stocking density (fish/ha).
  • Rice crop duration and harvesting frequency.
  • Total food production per unit of land.

Suitable fish species may include common carp, silver barb, tilapia, and other locally appropriate species depending on water depth, field conditions, climate, and market demand.

The comparison can determine whether fish production can be integrated without significantly reducing rice productivity. It can also identify suitable stocking densities and species combinations for different agroecological conditions.

An important consideration is that fish production should not be evaluated independently of rice yield. The combined output of rice and fish provides a more meaningful assessment of total agricultural productivity.

2. Evaluating water productivity and resource-use efficiency

Water productivity is an important indicator for assessing how efficiently agricultural systems use available water resources.

In conventional rice farming, water is mainly used to maintain suitable soil moisture and field-water conditions for rice growth. In integrated rice–fish farming, water management must also maintain sufficient depth and suitable environmental conditions for fish survival and growth.

The study could measure irrigation water input, rainfall contribution, water depth, drainage, and seasonal water consumption.

Rice water productivity can be estimated as:

Rice water productivity = Rice yield (kg) / Water consumed (m³)

Fish water productivity can be estimated as:

Fish water productivity = Fish yield (kg) / Water consumed (m³)

For integrated farming, combined food water productivity can be assessed using:

Combined water productivity = (Rice yield + Fish yield) / Total water consumed

However, rice and fish have different nutritional and economic values. Therefore, an additional economic water productivity indicator can be calculated:

Economic water productivity = Total farm revenue / Total water consumed

These indicators can help determine whether integrated farming produces greater food and economic output from the available water resources.

Water productivity should be calculated using a clearly defined water-accounting method. Rainfall, irrigation, water reuse, seepage, and drainage should be considered where relevant to avoid misleading comparisons between the two production systems.

3. Assessing soil health and nutrient dynamics

Soil health is another important component of sustainable rice–fish farming.

Rice fields are dynamic ecosystems where soil organisms, organic matter, nutrients, and water interact. Integrating fish may influence these processes through biological activity, nutrient recycling, and changes in organic matter decomposition.

Soil samples can be collected before and after the cultivation period to examine changes in important physical, chemical, and biological properties.

Potential indicators include:

  • Soil organic carbon.
  • Total nitrogen.
  • Available phosphorus.
  • Exchangeable potassium.
  • Soil pH.
  • Electrical conductivity.
  • Soil microbial biomass and activity.
  • Soil organic matter.

The study could investigate whether fish movement, natural food-web interactions, and nutrient recycling contribute to changes in soil fertility.

For example, fish excreta may contribute nitrogen and phosphorus to the field environment. However, the actual effect depends on fish stocking density, supplementary feeding, water exchange, fertilizer application, and nutrient losses.

Comparing soil conditions between integrated rice–fish and conventional rice plots would help identify differences in nutrient availability and the potential for improving long-term soil health.

4. Investigating climate variability and farming performance

Climate variability can influence rice growth, fish survival, water availability, and overall farm productivity.

Irregular rainfall may disrupt the availability of suitable water for both rice and fish. During prolonged dry periods, reduced field-water depth can increase temperature fluctuations and oxygen stress. On the other hand, excessive flooding may cause fish escape, damage rice plants, and increase production losses.

Historical rainfall and temperature records can be combined with field observations to evaluate the relationship between climatic conditions and farming performance.

Important variables may include:

  • Seasonal rainfall and rainfall distribution.
  • Maximum and minimum air temperature.
  • Water temperature.
  • Flood depth and duration.
  • Drought duration.
  • Water availability and irrigation frequency.
  • Dissolved oxygen concentration.

The study could compare farming performance during relatively dry, normal, and flood-affected seasons.

This would help determine whether integrated farming can provide more stable total food production and income under different climatic conditions.

5. Evaluating household food security and economic benefits

Agricultural productivity is not limited to the amount of food produced. The economic and nutritional benefits received by farming households are equally important.

Rice provides carbohydrates and energy, while fish supplies high-quality protein, essential fatty acids, vitamins, and minerals. Producing both commodities within the same farming system may improve household access to diverse foods.

A household-level survey could evaluate:

  • Annual rice and fish production.
  • Household fish consumption.
  • Farm income from rice and fish.
  • Production and input costs.
  • Market sales and seasonal income.
  • Household food availability and dietary diversity.
  • Farmers’ perceptions of climate-related production risks.

Economic indicators such as gross revenue, net profit, production cost, and benefit-cost ratio can be used to compare integrated rice–fish farming with conventional rice monoculture.

This would provide a broader understanding of whether increased production diversity translates into improved household welfare and food security.

How can the findings support climate-resilient agricultural planning?

The results of this research could support the development of more efficient and diversified agricultural production systems in Bangladesh.

Rice–fish farming could be promoted in suitable lowland, floodplain, and water-retaining agricultural areas where water availability, field structure, and local farming practices support fish culture.

Practical management strategies may include:

1. Improved field design: Constructing suitable trenches, refuges, and protective structures to provide fish with adequate water depth during dry periods and reduce fish escape during flooding.

2. Efficient water management: Maintaining appropriate water levels and coordinating irrigation practices to meet the requirements of both rice and fish. Water should be managed carefully to avoid unnecessary losses and maintain suitable environmental conditions.

3. Suitable fish species selection: Selecting locally appropriate fish species based on climate conditions, water depth, growth performance, feeding habits, and market demand.

4. Integrated nutrient management: Applying fertilizers and supplementary fish feeds appropriately while monitoring soil fertility and water quality. Excessive nutrient inputs should be avoided because they may negatively affect aquatic environmental conditions.

5. Climate-risk management: Developing suitable strategies for flood protection, drought management, temperature-related stress, and emergency fish harvesting during extreme weather events.

6. Economic and food-security assessment: Comparing production costs, net income, rice availability, fish consumption, and household nutritional benefits between the two systems.

7. Farmer training and institutional support: Providing technical training, access to quality fish seed, affordable credit, extension services, and market connections to encourage adoption among smallholder farmers.

These approaches could help farmers use the same agricultural land more efficiently while diversifying their sources of food and income.

Why does this research matter?

Bangladesh faces the challenge of maintaining agricultural production while responding to climate variability, limited land availability, freshwater constraints, and increasing food demand.

Conventional rice farming provides an essential staple food, but integrating fish production into suitable rice fields may offer additional opportunities for improving food diversity, farm income, and resource-use efficiency.

Evaluating water productivity, soil health, fish yield, and climate-related production risks together can provide a more comprehensive understanding of the benefits and limitations of integrated rice–fish farming.

The research is particularly important because higher total production does not automatically mean greater environmental sustainability. A successful integrated system must maintain rice productivity, support healthy fish growth, use water efficiently, and avoid long-term deterioration of soil and aquatic conditions.

Furthermore, the system may provide additional economic opportunities for smallholder farmers by creating multiple sources of agricultural income. Fish can be harvested and marketed at different times, potentially improving cash flow and reducing dependence on a single crop harvest.

The findings could be valuable for fisheries scientists, agricultural researchers, aquaculture professionals, extension officers, development organizations, and policymakers working toward sustainable food production.

Most importantly, this approach could help smallholder farmers produce rice and fish from the same land while strengthening their capacity to respond to environmental and economic challenges.

Looking ahead

Future research could establish comparative field trials in selected rice-producing regions of Bangladesh, including floodplain, haor, and northwestern agricultural areas, to evaluate rice–fish farming under different seasonal and climatic conditions.

A multi-season study would be particularly useful because a single production cycle may not adequately represent the effects of rainfall variation, drought, flooding, and temperature fluctuations.

Combining rice and fish production records with water-use measurements, soil-quality analysis, water-quality monitoring, and historical climate data could help identify the conditions under which integrated farming provides the greatest benefits.

GIS and remote sensing could also support the identification of suitable locations by examining land elevation, seasonal water availability, flood frequency, agricultural land-use patterns, and climatic conditions.

Ultimately, the goal is to develop a practical and climate-resilient rice–fish farming framework that improves water productivity, maintains soil health, increases food production, and strengthens the economic security of rural farming households in Bangladesh.

References

  1. Ahmed, N., & Garnett, S. T. (2011). Integrated rice-fish farming in Bangladesh: Meeting the challenges of food security. Food Security, 3, 81–92. https://doi.org/10.1007/s12571-011-0113-8
  2. Ahmed, N., Zander, K. K., & Garnett, S. T. (2011). Socioeconomic aspects of rice-fish farming in Bangladesh: Opportunities, challenges and production efficiency. The Australian Journal of Agricultural and Resource Economics, 55(2), 199–219. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1467-8489.2011.00535.x
  3. Islam, A. H. M. S., Barman, B. K., & Murshed-e-Jahan, K. (2015). Adoption and impact of integrated rice–fish farming system in Bangladesh. Aquaculture, 447, 76–85. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.aquaculture.2015.01.006
  4. Tabassum, T., Bashar, A., Haque, M. M., Alam, M. M., Rahman, M. Y., & Hasan, N. A. (2026). Development of rice-fish farming in enhancing economic and seasonal benefits: A case study from Bangladesh. Aquaculture Journal, 6(4), 49. https://doi.org/10.3390/aquacj6040049
  5. Mustafi, B. A. A. (2005). Adoption, productivity and profitability of rice-fish and fingerling culture in three selected districts of Bangladesh. Bangladesh Journal of Fisheries Research, 9(1), 83–85.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top